My Favorite Counter Makeup Products Formerly Beautycounter

Health + Wellness

Looking for the Beautycounter makeup you used to love? You’ll now find familiar favorites under Counter, including Skin Twin foundation, Dew Skin tinted moisturizer, cream blush, brow gel, and mascara. Beyond Gloss is back in the current lineup, too.

If you’ve been here for a while, you know I like makeup that fits into a real morning. Between training clients, teaching classes, and everything else on the calendar, I want getting ready to feel simple.

This guide brings together my longtime favorites and the current Counter products to look at if you’re rebuilding your makeup bag. I’ll also explain where I’d start depending on whether you want sheer coverage, a little more definition, or an easy lip color.

The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Shop Counter makeup through my link, or keep reading for help choosing where to start. Product and shade availability can change.

Skin Twin Featherweight Foundation for buildable coverage

Skin Twin has been part of my makeup routine for years. If you want more coverage than a tinted moisturizer, this is where I’d start.

Counter describes the current Skin Twin Featherweight Foundation as a lightweight formula with buildable coverage. That gives you room to apply a lighter layer and add more where you want it, rather than starting with a heavy application everywhere.

My advice: choose your shade based on your skin today. An old bottle can be a helpful reference, but it isn’t a reason to skip checking the current shade guide.

Consider this if: You want adjustable coverage and prefer a foundation over a sheer tint.

Shop Skin Twin Featherweight Foundation.

Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer for a sheer everyday look

If you prefer a lighter makeup look, Dew Skin is the alternative I’d consider. I’ve previously shared it on the blog for days when I want sheer coverage.

The current Dew Skin offers sheer coverage with a dewy finish. Think of it as a way to lightly even the appearance of your complexion while letting more of your natural skin show through.

The biggest shopping question is how much coverage you actually want. Choose Dew Skin for a sheer tint; consider Skin Twin if you want more coverage that you can build.

Consider this if: You like a fresh, dewy finish and don’t want your base to look very made up.

Shop Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer.

For more of my earlier experience, you can read my Beautycounter Dew Skin review. That post reflects the product I reviewed at the time; check the current listing for today’s details.

Skin Twin Creamy Concealer for targeted coverage

You don’t always need more foundation everywhere. Sometimes you want a little extra coverage under the eyes or around a specific area.

Skin Twin Creamy Concealer is now listed in Counter’s makeup lineup. Counter describes it as buildable, with a natural satin finish, for concealing dark circles and blemishes.

Start with a small amount where you want coverage, blend, and then decide whether you need more. Your concealer shade should suit the area you’re covering, rather than automatically being the lightest option.

Consider this if: You want to add coverage in a few places without changing your entire base routine.

Shop Skin Twin Creamy Concealer.

Cheeky Clean Cream Blush for a soft pop of color

Cream blush is an easy way to bring color into a simple makeup routine. Chai is one of the shades I’ve shared before, and it is listed in the current collection as a dusty rose.

Counter’s Cheeky Clean Cream Blush offers buildable color with a dewy finish and can be used on cheeks and lips. Start lightly and add color gradually so you can see how it works with your complexion.

If you love a very matte finish, take that into account before choosing a dewy cream formula. The right product should fit the look you enjoy wearing.

Consider this if: You want a soft wash of color and like cream textures.

Shop Cheeky Clean Cream Blush.

Brilliant Brow Tinted Brow Gel for natural definition

Even with microbladed brows, I’ve liked using tinted brow gel to add definition and help the hairs look more polished.

The current Brilliant Brow Tinted Brow Gel provides tint and a light hold. It’s worth considering if you want to shape and define your brows without creating a heavily drawn look.

A gel and a pencil do different jobs: gel adds tint and shapes existing hairs, while a pencil can help draw detail into areas where you want more definition.

Consider this if: You want a quick brow step with a softer hold.

Shop Brilliant Brow Tinted Brow Gel.

Think Big All-in-One Mascara for the finishing step

Mascara has long been one of my favorite ways to finish a simple makeup look. Think Big is the Counter mascara to look at if you’re returning to the brand.

Counter’s application directions suggest sweeping from the base of the lashes to the tips and adding coats to your desired effect. Start with one coat, then decide how much more definition you want.

You can keep the rest of your eye makeup simple. A base you like, a little cheek color, defined brows, and mascara already give you several ways to pull a look together.

Consider this if: You want lash definition as part of an everyday routine.

Shop Think Big All-in-One Mascara.

Beyond Gloss is back in Counter’s current lineup

If Beyond Gloss was one of your Beautycounter favorites, this is a return to know about. Counter currently lists nine shades, including Bare Shimmer, Rosewood, Peony, and Magnolia Shimmer—names I’ve shared in earlier favorites posts.

Counter describes the current gloss as high shine with a non-sticky feel. Here are a few shade descriptions to help narrow your choices:

Shade Counter’s current shade description

Bare Shimmer —> Neutral pink with shimmer

Rosewood —> Rosy brown

Peony —> Warm pink

Magnolia Shimmer —> Mauve with shimmer

Your Next Step Toward Glowing Health

If you’re replacing an old tube, check today’s shade images and description before ordering. A familiar shade name is a starting point, and your preferences may have changed since your last purchase.

Shop Counter Beyond Gloss.

Sheer Genius Conditioning Lipstick for creamy color

If you prefer lipstick to gloss, Sheer Genius is another longtime favorite I’ve written about. Lily and Terra are shades I’ve previously highlighted for an everyday look.

The current formula is described by Counter as creamy and buildable, with a light-catching sheen. That makes it a different finish to consider if you don’t want a very matte lip.

Consider this if: You want lipstick color with a softer, balmy feel.

Shop Sheer Genius Conditioning Lipstick.

Where I’d start with Counter makeup

You don’t need to replace your entire makeup bag at once. Start with the step you most want to improve.

What you’re looking for Product to consider

Sheer complexion coverage Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer

More adjustable complexion coverage Skin Twin Featherweight Foundation

Coverage in specific areas Skin Twin Creamy Concealer

Dewy cheek color Cheeky Clean Cream Blush

Tint and light hold for brows Brilliant Brow Tinted Brow Gel

Defined lashes Think Big All-in-One Mascara

A glossy lip finish Beyond Gloss

Creamy lipstick color Sheer Genius Conditioning Lipstick

For a shorter routine, choose one base product, a cheek color, mascara, and a lip product. Add other steps when they serve the look you want.

Need help choosing your Counter products

If you’re unsure where to start, email me at angie@angiebloom.com. Tell me what you currently use, what you like about it, and what you wish worked better. I’m happy to help you narrow down the options.

Shop Counter with Angie Bloom.

Thank you for shopping through my links and supporting my small business. I appreciate you being here!

You might also like: 

Here’s a great total body workout that you can do from home. As a personal trainer for over 20 years, the most important piece when it comes to your health is making sure you are CONSISTENT. If you aren’t consistent, then you will never see results.

I love seeing you all tag me on Instagram! It’s so fun when you complete a workout and show me your progress. Allow me to cheer you on! Tag me if you try this workout @__angiebloom__‍ ‍

One More Post I Think You’ll Love >>>

 

I created this brand to bring you the best in wellness, nutrition, fitness and clean beauty!

Discover your perfect skincare match—take the Oliveda quiz now and glow like never before!

 

A Favorite Post: Try my Favorite Healthy Cookie Dough

Previous
Previous

Counter Body Care for Dry Skin My Four Favorites and How to Choose

Next
Next

Healthy Pumpkin Bites: A Clean Fall Snack You'll Love